When You Don’t Need a Car Broker (From a Car Broker)

A silver SUV driving along a quiet country road in regional NSW at golden hour

A past client recently sent a mate our way. He lives regionally, he was after a new RAV4, and his local dealer had already given him a cracker of a price.

We went to market anyway and came back about $400 cheaper. On paper, that’s a win. In real life, the dealer with the sharper number was close to the city, about four hours from his place. He was looking at an eight-hour round trip to pick the car up, or a freight bill, and either way most of that $400 was gone.

A silver SUV driving along a quiet country road in regional NSW at golden hour

So we told him to buy it from his local dealer. We didn’t make a cent on that one.

It’s an odd story for a car broker to tell. But there are times you genuinely don’t need one, and we’d rather say so up front.

So, do you need a car broker?

Not always. If the car you want sells at a fixed price, if you’re buying used, or if you already know your price is sharp, you can skip the broker.

If you’re buying a new car from a brand that negotiates, and all you’ve got is one dealer’s number, a broker will usually save you money and a few weekends.

Here’s how to tell which side of that line you’re on.

When you can skip us

The brand has one national price

Tesla, BYD, Honda and Mercedes-Benz, among others, sell at a fixed price. The number on their website is the number everyone pays, whichever showroom you walk into. There’s no dealer to play off against another, so there’s nothing for us to negotiate.

If that’s your next car, order it direct and save yourself the extra phone call.

You’re buying used

We only source brand new cars. If you’ve got your eye on a two-year-old Ranger with 40,000 km on the clock, we’re not your people.

You’d rather negotiate it yourself

Some people enjoy the back and forth, know the market and have a few Saturdays to spare. If that’s you, go for it. You may well land a sharp price on your own.

A woman at a dealership desk reading through a new car quote

A few things will help. Get at least three written drive-away quotes on the identical car: same variant, same colour, same options. Keep your trade-in out of the conversation until the price is agreed. And remember what you’re up against. You might get to three or four dealers in a weekend. We work with more than 950 around the country, and they know they’re quoting against each other.

You’ve already been given a cracker of a price

Like our RAV4 buyer. It does happen, and when it does, we’ll tell you.

The catch: most people think they’re in that last group

Nearly everyone who drives out of a dealership believes they got a good deal. The salesperson went to see the manager twice, threw in a set of floor mats and swore they’d never sold one cheaper.

But unless you’ve seen what the exact same car is going for elsewhere, you don’t really know. That’s what got us started back in 2020: people were landing what felt like a good deal, with no way of knowing whether it actually was.

We’ve seen it go both ways. The RAV4 buyer’s price held up.

Another client came to us because her hairdresser told her to. She’d bought her last two cars from the same dealership and was planning to sign for her third that very afternoon. Her hairdresser convinced her to at least give us a call first. We ended up saving her a further $6,800 on the price she’d already been told she was being “looked after” on.

Nobody did anything wrong there. She simply had one number and nothing to hold it up against. Both of them thought they had a good price. Only one of them did, and neither could have told you which beforehand.

The $1,000 test

So here’s an easy way to check. Would you bet $1,000 that no dealer within a sensible drive of you would beat the price you’ve been offered?

A man in his car checking a new car quote on his phone

If you’d take that bet without blinking, you probably don’t need us.

If you’d hesitate, send us your quote before you sign. Screenshot it and message us on Facebook or Instagram, or email it to enquiries@thecarconcierge.com.au.

Your quote stays with us. We only use it to make sure we’re pricing the identical car. Then we go to market the way we always do and show you what comes back, usually within 24 to 48 hours.

Most of the time, we come back cheaper. When we don’t, we’ll tell you your price holds up, just like we did with the RAV4.

“If the dealer pays you, whose side are you on?”

Fair question. We’d ask it too.

Our fee is paid by the dealership that supplies your car, so you don’t pay us a cent. That fee is the same whichever dealer wins the deal, and it’s the same whether you pay $45,000 or $48,000 for the car. We don’t earn a dollar more if you pay more.

We also only get paid if you choose a quote we’ve found. So the only way we earn anything is by bringing you the sharpest one.

And sometimes the right answer is the price you’ve already got. That’s what we told the RAV4 buyer, and he’s since sent a few people our way. We’ll take that over a quick sale any day.

When we’re worth a call

If you’re buying a brand that does negotiate, like Toyota, Ford, Mazda, Hyundai or Kia, and all you’ve got is one dealer’s price, send it through and we’ll show you how it stacks up.

Same if the car you want has a long wait and you’d like to know whether one is sitting on a lot somewhere else. Or if you’d simply rather not spend your Saturdays in car yards.

Our founder has been in the car industry since 2005, and we have 450+ reviews across Google and Facebook from people who’ve bought this way. If you’re new to the idea, here’s what a car concierge actually does.

Call 1300 530 967, email enquiries@thecarconcierge.com.au, or request pricing on our website. It’s free, and there’s no obligation.

Free, no obligation

Got a car in mind, or a quote already?

Tell us the car, or send us the quote you’ve been given. Our network of 950+ dealers competes to win your business, and pricing usually comes back within 24 to 48 hours.

Dan Biady, founder of The Car Concierge Australia

About the author

Dan Biady

Founder, The Car Concierge Australia

Dan has worked in the car industry since 2005 and founded The Car Concierge Australia in 2020. His team sources brand new cars for buyers and businesses Australia-wide, with finance through a panel of 50+ lenders, novated leasing and fleet.

Connect with Dan on LinkedIn →

← More car buying insights